Goodmorningquotess
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Home
  • World
  • Opinion
  • Economy
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Lifestyle
    What Demi Lovato reveals in ‘Dancing with the Devil’ album

    What Demi Lovato reveals in ‘Dancing with the Devil’ album

    Google cancels April Fools’ Day, again

    Google cancels April Fools’ Day, again

    Biting Britcom ‘Back’ returns after four years

    Biting Britcom ‘Back’ returns after four years

    Sylvester Stallone reveals notes for ‘Rocky’ TV series

    Sylvester Stallone reveals notes for ‘Rocky’ TV series

    SNL takes aim at Joe Biden, Kamala Harris with Unity Seder skit

    SNL takes aim at Joe Biden, Kamala Harris with Unity Seder skit

    Top 10 TV Shows to Binge Watch During Lockdown

    Trending Tags

    • COVID-19
    • Donald Trump
    • Pandemic
    • Bill Gates
    • Corona Virus
  • Tech
PRICING
SUBSCRIBE
  • Home
  • World
  • Opinion
  • Economy
  • Business
  • Culture
  • Politics
  • Lifestyle
    What Demi Lovato reveals in ‘Dancing with the Devil’ album

    What Demi Lovato reveals in ‘Dancing with the Devil’ album

    Google cancels April Fools’ Day, again

    Google cancels April Fools’ Day, again

    Biting Britcom ‘Back’ returns after four years

    Biting Britcom ‘Back’ returns after four years

    Sylvester Stallone reveals notes for ‘Rocky’ TV series

    Sylvester Stallone reveals notes for ‘Rocky’ TV series

    SNL takes aim at Joe Biden, Kamala Harris with Unity Seder skit

    SNL takes aim at Joe Biden, Kamala Harris with Unity Seder skit

    Top 10 TV Shows to Binge Watch During Lockdown

    Trending Tags

    • COVID-19
    • Donald Trump
    • Pandemic
    • Bill Gates
    • Corona Virus
  • Tech
No Result
View All Result
Goodmorningquotess
No Result
View All Result
Home Featured

Supreme Court Considers Whether Patent Judges Were Properly Appointed

admin by admin
March 1, 2021
Reading Time:4min read
0
Supreme Court Considers Whether Patent Judges Were Properly Appointed


WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Monday took a hard look at whether more than 250 administrative judges who hear patent disputes, some of them over billions of dollars, had been appointed in violation of the Constitution.

Several justices indicated during the oral argument that they thought the judges, who serve on the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, an administrative tribunal in the executive branch created by a 2011 law, perform work of such importance and independence that they should have been appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate.

“This structure is a real break from tradition,” Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh said. “These are multimillion, sometimes billion-dollar decisions being made not by someone who’s accountable in the usual way.”

The Constitution’s separation of power, he said, forbids Congress from insulating officials in the executive branch with significant authority — even ones whose job it is to adjudicate disputes — from presidential control.

Malcolm L. Stewart, a lawyer for the federal government, said the patent judges, who were appointed by the commerce secretary in consultation with the director of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, were adequately supervised by the director, who like the commerce secretary is appointed by the president and subject to Senate confirmation. The director, he said, provided the judges with enough oversight that they were not “principal officers” who themselves required presidential appointment.

“The director can promulgate binding guidance concerning substantive patent law,” Mr. Stewart said. “He can designate particular board opinions as precedential, thus making those opinions binding on future panels. He can also decide whether any particular review will be instituted and which judges will sit on the panel.”

Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. responded that those methods “seem to be more or less ways of twisting the arms” of the patent judges that fell short of the required direct control. The one thing the director cannot do, the chief justice said, is change a decision issued by a panel of patent judges.

The case, United States v. Arthrex, No. 19-1434, arose from a challenge filed by Smith & Nephew, a medical technology company, against patents held by a competitor, Arthrex, on a medical device. A panel of patent judges ruled that Arthrex’s patents were invalid.

Arthrex appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, a specialized court in Washington, saying that the patent judges’ decision should be thrown out because they had not been properly appointed.

The appeals court agreed, ruling that the judges performed important work without supervision and so were “principal officers” under the Constitution, meaning that they had to be appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate.

On Monday, Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked how it was possible to reconcile judicial independence, even for administrative judges, and presidential control. “Isn’t that totally at odds with an adjudicatory system of any kind?” she said.

Mark A. Perry, a lawyer for Smith & Nephew, said that conflict justified a flexible approach by Congress, one that should allow the current system. “There is an inherent tension in agency adjudicatory-type proceedings between adjudicative independence and presidential control,” he said, “and that balance can be struck by Congress in many, many ways and throughout history has been struck in many, many ways so long as the channels of authority are preserved.”

But Jeffrey A. Lamken, a lawyer for Arthrex, said more supervision was required for executive-branch officials who have the “final word resolving billion-dollar disputes affecting the innovation landscape.”

“For the parties aggrieved by the loss of valuable rights,” he said, “there’s no superior they can go to to ask them to countermand that bad decision.”

The appeals court’s solution to the constitutional problem was to strike down a part of the law that protected the patent judges from being fired without cause. This effectively demoted them from “principal officers,” the appeals court said.

The Supreme Court did not seem likely to adopt that particular fix, and there did not appear to be a consensus about what should follow from a ruling that the patent judges had been appointed in violation of the Constitution.

The Supreme Court’s decision will affect more than 100 cases that have been vacated by the appeals court, which had initially ordered them to be reheard by panels of newly demoted patent judges. Those hearings have been suspended while the justices consider the case before them.



Source link

RELATED POSTS

What Demi Lovato reveals in ‘Dancing with the Devil’ album

Google cancels April Fools’ Day, again

Biting Britcom ‘Back’ returns after four years

Support authors and subscribe to content

This is premium stuff. Subscribe to read the entire article.

Login if you have purchased

Subscribe

Gain access to all our Premium contents.
More than 100+ articles.
Subscribe Now

Buy Article

Unlock this article and gain permanent access to read it.
Unlock Now
ShareTweetPin
admin

admin

Related Posts

What Demi Lovato reveals in ‘Dancing with the Devil’ album
Featured

What Demi Lovato reveals in ‘Dancing with the Devil’ album

April 2, 2021
Google cancels April Fools’ Day, again
Featured

Google cancels April Fools’ Day, again

April 1, 2021
Biting Britcom ‘Back’ returns after four years
Featured

Biting Britcom ‘Back’ returns after four years

March 31, 2021
Sylvester Stallone reveals notes for ‘Rocky’ TV series
Featured

Sylvester Stallone reveals notes for ‘Rocky’ TV series

March 30, 2021
SNL takes aim at Joe Biden, Kamala Harris with Unity Seder skit
Featured

SNL takes aim at Joe Biden, Kamala Harris with Unity Seder skit

March 29, 2021
Judy Blume’s one regret about Beverly Cleary
Featured

Judy Blume’s one regret about Beverly Cleary

March 28, 2021
Next Post
Where to buy Jason Sudeikis’ Golden Globes hoodie

Where to buy Jason Sudeikis’ Golden Globes hoodie

Warren Revives Wealth Tax, Citing Pandemic Inequalities

Warren Revives Wealth Tax, Citing Pandemic Inequalities

Recommended Stories

New Yorkers Say Cuomo Shouldn’t Resign (or Run for Re-election)

New Yorkers Say Cuomo Shouldn’t Resign (or Run for Re-election)

March 5, 2021
Osama bin Laden’s son is an avid painter of Americana

Osama bin Laden’s son is an avid painter of Americana

March 2, 2021
The 10 artists who’ve won the most Grammys Awards ever

The 10 artists who’ve won the most Grammys Awards ever

March 14, 2021

Popular Stories

  • Biden Says He Plans to Run for Re-Election in 2024

    Biden Says He Plans to Run for Re-Election in 2024

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Biden Administration Announces Ad Campaign to Combat Vaccine Hesitancy

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Four Dead in Southern California Office Shooting

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Google cancels April Fools’ Day, again

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The best, most insane reality TV show moments of all time

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Goodmorningquotess

We bring you the best Premium WordPress Themes that perfect for news, magazine, personal blog, etc. Visit our landing page to see all features & demos.

LEARN MORE »

Recent Posts

  • Volkswagen US chief takes blame for ‘Voltswagen’ debacle
  • Weekly Health Quiz: An Australian Mystery, Covid and the Teenage Brain
  • Turing Award Goes to Creators of Computer Programming Building Blocks

Categories

  • Business
  • Culture
  • Economy
  • Featured
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • Uncategorized
  • World

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Subscription
  • Category
    • Business
    • Culture
    • Economy
    • Lifestyle
    • Health
    • Travel
    • Opinion
    • Politics
    • Tech
    • World
  • Landing Page
  • Buy JNews
  • Support Forum
  • Pre-sale Question
  • Contact Us

© 2021 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?